From One Rival to 30 Real Prospects: Building an Outreach List With Competitor Link Data
Photo by Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash on Unsplash
Most outreach campaigns die in the spreadsheet, not the inbox. You fire off 400 emails, get nine replies, and maybe two lukewarm maybes. The subject line wasn't the problem. Half the list was coupon aggregators, dead directories, and sites that stopped publishing when TikTok was still Musical.ly.
The fix is not more emails. It's a smaller, sharper list. What follows is the workflow we run at MBacklinks when we want to convert a single competitor into roughly 30 outreach targets worth a real human being's time.
Pick a competitor that actually overlaps with you
Beginners grab the biggest site in the niche and export 40,000 referring domains. That's a data dump, not intelligence. A site with 500,000 backlinks is getting linked for reasons that have nothing to do with you — brand news coverage, a podcast network, a decade of legacy relationships.
Instead, look for the site ranking in positions 3 through 10 for your money keywords. It has enough authority to attract links but not so much that its profile is unreachable. Ideally it's in the same topical lane: same product categories, same type of content, similar audience. If you run a US-focused home gym affiliate site, a competitor ranking for "best adjustable dumbbells" is a far better source than a general fitness magazine.
Pick two or three of these mid-tier rivals if you can. Overlap is your best filter — a domain that links to all three is almost certainly a genuinely relevant target.
Export referring domains, not individual backlinks
This is the step people skip. Backlink exports give you noise: 12 links from the same site footer, syndicated press releases, comment spam. Referring domains collapse all of that into one row per site, which is what you actually want to evaluate.
In Ahrefs, Semrush, or Majestic, pull the referring domains report and export the whole thing. Keep the columns for domain rating or authority, traffic estimate, first seen date, link type (follow versus nofollow), and the page the link points to. You'll need those later.
Score topical relevance before anything else
Before you look at authority, look at subject matter. Ask a blunt question: would this site plausibly link to my content, on purpose, with a human editor behind the decision?
Three quick checks:
- Category match. Does the domain cover your topic, or a neighboring one? A site about running shoes linking to a dumbbell review is a stretch; a site about home fitness is not.
- Language and market. If you sell to US buyers, a Polish or Brazilian directory is a red flag, not an opportunity.
- Editorial vs. commercial. Does the site publish articles with bylines, or is it a page of outbound links with a logo slapped on top? The second kind is a link farm, and it's a waste of an email.
Sanity-check the traffic
Traffic estimates are rough, but you only need order of magnitude. A domain claiming 40,000 monthly visits with zero indexed pages that rank is fiction. A domain with 800 visits but a tight, engaged niche audience might be gold.
Two things to verify quickly: whether the site has any organic keywords at all, and whether the pages linking to your competitor are actually live. Broken link targets are a different campaign.
Treat authority as a tiebreaker, not a gate
Here's where lists get ruined. People set a hard cutoff — say domain rating 40 and above — and throw away perfectly good prospects sitting at 28 with real editorial standards and a small but devoted readership.
Use authority to rank the survivors, not to filter the field. If you have 60 relevant domains, sorting by authority is reasonable. If you have 60 relevant domains and you delete the bottom 30 because of a number, you've just thrown away half your opportunity for no reason.
Kill the junk with four fast rules
Before anything reaches a prospect sheet, remove:
- Directories and submission sites — general web directories, free listing pages, and anything that accepts every URL submitted.
- Link farms and PBN footprints — dozens of unrelated outbound links per page, hosted on cheap shared infrastructure, thin or scraped content.
- Irrelevant aggregators — coupon scrapers, price comparison shells, and auto-generated content mills.
- Dead or dormant sites — no new posts in 18 months, broken layout, no real social footprint.
This is where the MBacklinks approach earns its keep. You are not prospecting. You are eliminating. What survives is your actual market.
Cut to 30 and write the sheet
If you've done the steps properly, you should be sitting on 40 to 80 viable domains from one competitor. Trim to 30 by ranking on a simple composite: relevance, then traffic plausibility, then authority.
Your sheet needs, at minimum: domain, contact page or editor name, the specific competitor page they linked to, the topic you'd pitch, and a notes field. That last column matters — jot down what the site covers and why you'd fit. Personalization later gets much easier when the notes are already there.
Thirty is a deliberate number. It's small enough to research each target properly and big enough to produce a reasonable reply rate. Six to ten links from 30 well-chosen pitches beats one link from 400 scattershot ones, and it doesn't torch your domain's sender reputation along the way.
A word on follow-through
Export the list once and it goes stale in about six weeks. Sites get sold, editors move on, pages drop. Re-run the export monthly on the same competitor set and you'll see new referring domains appear — those are the freshest, most actionable targets you'll ever get, because someone just decided this topic deserves a link.
That's the whole loop: one competitor, one export, one filter pass, 30 names. Repeat it every month and you'll never send a blind email again.